Advertisement
Home News Local News

OPINION: Why is Tony Abbott punishing us for procreating?

The new paid parental leave scheme makes it even harder to balance a career and motherhood, writes Zoe Arnold.
Prime Minister Tony Abbott

Double-dipping. It sounds more like something a poor-mannered guest would do at a lazy Sunday afternoon BBQ than a method to get more time off with your newborn child, but turns out โ€˜double-dippingโ€™ is the new way for women to afford to have babies in this country.

Advertisement

The premise is simple: as a public-sector worker (think teachers, nurses, bureaucrats et al ), you can claim your parental leave once from your employer โ€“ then again as part of the governmentโ€™s paid parental leave scheme.

For NSW public school teachers, it means 18 weeks of paid leave on your teacherโ€™s salary, and another 18 weeks paid at the federally mandated minimum wage = 36 weeks, or around 9 months off with your newborn. Similar leave provisions exist across the public sector.

The same applies for some larger corporations and non-for-profits, while small businesses tend to rely on the governmentโ€™s scheme.

Enter the Abbottโ€™s Motherโ€™s Day โ€˜giftโ€™ to women: as of tomorrowโ€™s budget, you can double-dip no more. Women will be instead be eligible for one payment only โ€“ meaning for an estimated 80,000 parents-to-be across Australia, they will be forced back to work sooner.

Advertisement

In principle, double-dipping seems unfair to me. Why is it that public sector employees should get a bonus for their career choice, but I should suffer because of mine? Many commentators agree โ€“ claiming a billion dollars a year is handed-out to so-called โ€˜double-dippersโ€™.

However, these commentators are missing something quite fundamental: even with double-dipping, our parental leave schemes are nowhere near generous enough.

Four-and-a-half months to work out breastfeeding, sleeping patterns and childcare arrangements just ainโ€™t right. At that time post-partum, I was an exhausted mess. Sleep-deprived, dealing with multiple rounds of mastitis, vomit-covered โ€ฆ I was in no state to switch off my baby-brain and head back into a work environment.

If you had told me that I had to front up to an office, I know I would have done little more than sobbed into my cold cup of tea. However, by the time my kids were 10 months old respectively, I was ready to re-join the workforce, and eager to be a โ€˜productiveโ€™ working mother. I ached for adult conversation that didnโ€™t revolve around sleep-cycles and infant bowel movements, and was ready to make the transition.

Advertisement

My experience isnโ€™t for everyone โ€“ and there will always been some women who feel confident about re-joining the workforce shortly after birth. Thatโ€™s okay too.

The point is that in 2015, women deserve to have a choice.

In Norway, parents get 37 weeks shared parental leave at full pay, on top of their โ€˜mother-onlyโ€™ and โ€˜father-onlyโ€™ leave. Ditto in Denmark, where mums and dads receive 32 weeks parental leave. How novel โ€“ long periods of leave โ€“ and a choice between which parent can take it!

Double-dipping isnโ€™t right: women shouldnโ€™t be forced to choose an employer or career path based on leave provisions alone. Equally, a woman in the public sector shouldnโ€™t get double what someone does in the private sector just because they have different employers.

Advertisement

But cutting parental leave payments isnโ€™t right either. If women are supposed to balance a career and motherhood, there needs to be some incentive to do so. We shouldnโ€™t be punished for procreating.

What the changes mean for you:

If anyone tells you they actually understand childcare benefits and payments, theyโ€™re probably lying. Itโ€™s a quagmire: a mess of statistics and hourly rates, of rebates and benefits (which are not the same thing). Budget 2015 brings a whole new system โ€“ explained in plain English, below.

Advertisement

So will I be worse off?

Stay-at-home mums are the losers. No longer will you be able to claim a benefit from using childcare โ€“ if you use childcare; it will be 100% out-of-pocket, unless you start working part-time.

Additionally, Family Tax Benefit B is being cut. Itโ€™s currently provided to single parents or single-income families on a means-tested basis, for kids up to age 16.

Now it will stop when your kids turn six. Itโ€™s a punishment for single parent families, who appear to be the losers from this arrangement.

Advertisement
Abbott skolling a beer
Prime Minister Tony Abbott skolls a beer at a Sydney pub.
0 seconds of 10 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:10
00:10
 

Related stories


Unwind and relax with your favourite magazine!

Huge savings plus FREE home delivery

Advertisement
Advertisement